For lenders, landlords and HR teams

Income verification and fake pay stubs

Online generators make a pay stub or W-2 in minutes, and editing a real one is easier still. Here is how to check income documents before you approve a loan or a lease.

0 of 6 red flagsTick any red flag you see.

Have a photo or screenshot of it? Scan it for AI generation and edits. Nothing on this checklist is stored.

Red flags

What fakes usually get wrong

Numbers that don't add up

Gross minus deductions doesn't equal net, or year-to-date totals don't grow with each pay period.

Taxes that look wrong

Federal, state and FICA withholding that are missing, round or don't match the stated income.

Employer that can't be found

No real business, phone number or EIN for the employer named.

W-2 and pay stubs disagree

Annual W-2 wages that don't match the year-to-date figure on the last pay stub.

Limits

  • Witness checks images for AI generation and editing. It does not read the text, check the numbers or confirm the document with whoever issued it. For a PDF, ask for the original or screenshot the page.
  • A document from a pay stub generator can be a clean, unedited image with invented numbers. Employer or IRS verification is what catches those.

How it works

  1. 01

    Do the payroll math

    Check net pay, year-to-date totals and withholding. Generated stubs often fail here.

  2. 02

    Scan the image

    Run the photo or screenshot through Witness. It returns a likelihood that the image was AI-generated or edited, with a heatmap of where.

  3. 03

    Verify with the employer or IRS

    Use an employment verification service, call the employer, or request an IRS tax transcript with consent.

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell if a pay stub is fake?

Check that gross minus deductions equals net, that year-to-date totals add up across stubs, and that withholding makes sense. Then verify employment directly.

Can Witness detect a fake pay stub?

Witness can check a pay stub, W-2 or 1099 image for signs of editing or AI generation. It does not check the numbers or the employer, so do those checks too.

What is the most reliable income verification?

Direct confirmation: an employment verification service, the employer's HR team, or an IRS tax transcript requested with the applicant's consent.

Related

Don't guess. Witness it.

Free to try. No account needed for your first scans. Witness gives a likelihood with a confidence percentage, not a certainty.